FAQs on Calcium
Gluconate
Related Articles: Calcium, Calcium Reactors,
The Top 10 (Plus) Frequently Asked
Questions about Calcium Reactors by Jason Chodakowski
Calcium Reactors and How They Work
by James Gasta,
The Use of Kalkwasser
by Russell Schultz, Understanding Calcium &
Alkalinity, Live Sand,
Marine Substrates, Reef Systems,
Refugiums,
Related FAQs: Calcium, FAQs 1, Calcium FAQs 2, Calcium FAQs 3, Calcium FAQs 4, Calcium FAQs 5, Calcium FAQs 6. & FAQs on
Calcium: Rationale/Use, Calcium
Measuring/Test Kits, Sources of
Calcium, Calcium Supplements,
Dosing, Chemical/Physical Interactions, Troubleshooting/Fixing, & Calcium Reactors,
& FAQs on Calcium Reactors: Rationale/Use, Selection, Installation, Operation, Media, Measuring, Trouble-Shooting, By Makes/Models, &
Calcium and Alkalinity, Kalkwasser & FAQs on: The Science of Calcium
& Alkalinity, Importance,
Measure, Sources, Use of
Additives, Troubleshooting/Fixing, Products,
|
|
Calcium gluconate irritating polyps? --
12/29/11
Hi wonderful experts! I have a mystery, and I'd love to know
if anyone has a thought on this.
<Let's see>
I have read here and elsewhere that calcium gluconate is a wonderful
coraline algae stimulant,
<Mmm, can be... depends on the make-up of the system, water... not a
"blank check" to boosting coraline, and does have its
limits>
so I bought a bottle from a well known, highly respected maker of reef
chemicals. I recently set up a smallish tank containing only star
polyps, Zoanthids, and a few mushrooms.
<These organisms are all strongly chemically allelopathogenic...
best for you to search, read re on WWM>
They are all thriving. But several weeks ago, when I
added a recommended does of calcium gluconate for the first
time,
<How was this added? Should only be done in a dissolved
state...>
all of the star polyps snapped shut and remained closed for the rest of
the day. A week later the same thing happened. Yesterday I
added the normal dose (my third time doing it, though now with some
hesitation!). Then I got stupid... my wife (her fault, of
course!) asked me a question, I answered it, and without thinking I
added a second spoonful to the tank, <As a solid;
mistake>
thus giving it a double dose. Well... the reaction was swift and
violent.
All star polyps snapped shut. But this time, EVERY Zoanthid
closed up also. A half hour later, every mushroom had cupped up
tight, showing only their undersides. Today, a day later,
everything is back to normal except for the star polyps, which are just
beginning to open. I'm strongly inclined to never use this
stuff again. Does anyone have a comment on this?
Thanks!
Tim
<Umm, irritating as added. Thoroughly dissolve before adding. Bob
Fenner>
Re: Calcium gluconate irritating polyps? 12/29/11
Bob - Thanks for the quick reply! Actually, it is in liquid
form. It is SeaChem Reef Calcium.
<Ahh, I see... best still to dilute, introduce let's say during
water change-outs>
As for the allelopathogenic properties, my understanding is that the
mushrooms are the worst, the star polyps are second, and small
Zoanthids have very little potency (other than the palytoxin danger to
animals). Is this correct?
<Mmm, I'd rank the Clavulariids at the top, and Zoanthids and
Corallimorpharians are quite variable... some innocuous, others, very
toxic at times>
In any case, most of these assorted corals are on individual
smallish live rocks so that if any becomes a problem it will be easy to
pull them out and either trim back or remove entirely.
<I see... again, there are means to alleviate a good deal of
negative interaction. Do see my ppt on such posted on WWM>
But this violent reaction to the calcium gluconate solution is a real
mystery. It is absolutely repeatable and dramatic. My star
polyps remain closed for at least a day, sometimes two days, after I
add that stuff.
Other additions, such as water changes, Kalk, 2-part calcium/alkalinity
boosters (which I almost never need), and iodine, do not impact them at
all.
Tim
|
|